How the Index measures
We ask four AI engines the same 600 US shopping and money questions again and again (five runs in October 2026, weekly from November) and store every answer. The Index shows which sites those answers link next to their claims. It measures; no one can buy a place in it.
- Fixed questions
- 600 questions across 40 subcategories, fixed since 22 October 2026, so most changes come from the engines. Engines and data providers also change how answers are delivered; every run is checked for that.
- Four engines
- ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews, asked from the United States.
- Every answer kept
- Each answer and its sources are stored, so every number traces back to real answers. Pages show examples; the full set is available on request.
- Same rules for everyone
- Every site is counted by the same code from the same answers. No one can pay to change a number or be left out. ToldBy also sells AI-visibility reports; customers are counted exactly like everyone else.
Definitions
- Answer
- One engine's reply to one question in one measurement.
- Answer with a linked source
- An answer that links at least one site next to a claim. All shares use these.
- Site
- A website by its main domain (money.usnews.com counts as usnews.com).
- Linked
- The site is linked inside the answer, next to the claim it supports: the source link or chip beside a sentence or paragraph. This is the Index's main measure.
- Listed
- The site appears only in the answer's list of sources, not next to a claim.
- Linked or listed
- The site appears anywhere in the answer's sources, next to a claim or not.
- Link next to a claim
- One source link placed next to a claim in an answer. An answer can link the same site or page more than once.
- Citation
- A site linked next to a claim in an answer, counted once per answer and site, however many links it has there.
- Page link
- A page linked next to a claim in an answer, counted once per answer and page.
- All engines
- The four engines pooled. ChatGPT and Gemini answers count half, because each question is asked twice there. Engines with fewer answers that have sources (often AI Overviews, which Google doesn't always show) weigh less.
- Media group
- Answers that link at least one site the group owns. A group is counted once per answer.
- 95% range
- How much the number could move with a different set of questions of the same kind. It doesn't cover changes in the engines from one run to the next.
- Rank
- #1 is the highest share. “joint #3” means another entry shows the same share.
- Engine overlap (top 10)
- The share of their top-10 sites two engines have in common: 4 shared sites = 40%.
- Brand named
- Answers that name the brand as a pick or an alternative.
- Example answers
- The panel that opens when you click a number. Its count is the number of stored answers behind it.
Numbers whose base is fewer than 30 answers are marked “small sample”; fewer than 10 are hidden. Most sites appear in only a few answers, so ranks far down a list mean little.
This release
Five runs in October 2026, then one run a week from November. The numbers on the pages combine all runs so far, each counting the same.
Good to know
- The same question can get different sources each time it’s asked. That’s why every number pools many answers and shows a range.
- The questions cover each subcategory’s main buying decisions. They are buying questions only, asked in the US, signed out; a signed-in or paid user can see different answers.
- A share of zero means the engine didn’t link the site in our answers. Some sites block certain AI crawlers, which keeps them out of that engine’s answers.
- Think a site’s label or owner is wrong? Tell us and we’ll fix it in the next release.